Mad Detective

2007 [CHINESE]

Action / Crime / Mystery / Thriller

15
Rotten Tomatoes Critics - Certified Fresh 80% · 20 reviews
Rotten Tomatoes Audience - Upright 85% · 2.5K ratings
IMDb Rating 7.1/10 10 8410 8.4K

Plot summary

Bun, a schizophrenic, former police inspector comes out of retirement to help a rookie detective solve a complex murder case involving a missing colleague and a suspected policeman suffering from a multiple personality disorder.

Director

Top cast

Andy On as Inspector Ho Ka-on
Soi Cheang as Inspector Ho Ka-on
Siu-Fai Cheung as Violent Man - Ko's Inner Personality
Jonathan Yat-Sing Lee as Weak Boy - Ho's Inner Personality
720p.BLU 1080p.BLU
821.71 MB
1280*538
Chinese 2.0
NR
Subtitles us  
24 fps
1 hr 29 min
Seeds 3
1.65 GB
1904*800
Chinese 5.1
NR
Subtitles us  
24 fps
1 hr 29 min
Seeds 11

Movie Reviews

Reviewed by boblipton 6 / 10

Too Many Questions, Too Few Answers

Eighteen months before this movie begins, two cops pursued a suspect into a forest. The suspect got away. One cop came out. Since then, the missing man's gun has been used in a wide variety of robberies. Inspector Andy On is in charge of the case so far as the robberies and attendant murders are concerned. He has run out of leads. So he recruits Ching-Wan Lau, a disgraced former cop whose career ended in apparent madness in which he claimed supernatural powers.There's no madness in the Chinese title; it means "Hard Boiled." The English title is supposed to clue the audience into the fact that there's at least one insane cop here, but as the story advances, the question of who is mad becomes murky. Is it On, whose efforts to close the case become increasingly unhinged? Is it Lau, who has ceased to take his prescribed anti-psychotic medicines, and who has constructed a fantasy world in which he is still with his ex-wife, Kelly Lin? Or is it the dead man's partner, who says he is investigating what he believes is his partner's murder? It all ends in a shoot-out in a hall of mirrors, but will anything really be resolved?Directors Johnny To and Ka-Fai Wai have created another stylish crime drama in To's signature blue-lit world in the midst of blackness that constantly shifts the size and shape of the audience's frame. It's all very interesting to watch, but in the end there is no release from the nightmare world that is traditional for detective stories, even one as murky as this.
Reviewed by

Reviewed by paranoica 7 / 10

Plain fun

The story follows a somewhat not-so-sane Hongkong police detective Bun (Lau) who, after solving a crime in "his own way" during the opening sequence of the movie, cuts half his ear off, gets suspended from the force and has to lead on his miserable private life, mainly communicating with the creations of his own mind. As some years have passed, another cop in HK police gets missing in action and Ho (On), a former member of Bun's investigation unit, gets the case and decides to call Bun for help.

The flick is (as title refers) a bit on the side of madness. Though, it doesn't truly get deeply attached to the theme, offering a light view of one side of it. Seems that directors Johnny To and Ka-Fai Wai decided to rule out everything that would "ruin" the picture for audiences more on the side of police-thriller. Bun's tendency to descend to schizophrenia is opened to the viewer quite early in the film and also simply, making it clear that it's just a part of film we wouldn't miss. So everything is opened up for the viewer, just enjoy the story (which doesn't offer too much) and enjoy the acting. A bit of non-linear scene-switching, but that wouldn't bother anyone who doesn't still live in 60's.

Bun's character is the star of this film and Ching Wan Lau plays the role well. Comic at times (a super-cop with half an ear and - during most of the film - a bloody bandage wrapped around his head, looking like a bum after a weekly party) but mainly socializing with inner world of himself and - as he states he can see the 'inner personality' of people - those around him. Especially the lovely relationship with his imaginary wife: everything that's worthy to love in her, everything feminine, was hooked to the image of his mind, so when the real wife (now an ex) finally showed up, the only qualities left for her were those of a mean bitch's.

The film would've been quite Hitchcock's style, if the schizophrenic part of Bun had been left unveiled for a longer period of the movie (as the master hinted to play with the audience, not only caress them). What bothered the most - these god damn in fashion hair cuts - why do the characters have to look like the cover picture of some fashion magazine? It's one of the weakest links in almost all modern Asian movies.

3/5

Read more IMDb reviews

1 Comment

Be the first to leave a comment